Small Trailer Instead Of A Truck?

That sounds like a good idea.  Right?  There are a million good reasons to need the capacity of a pickup truck, but actually, very few people use a Truck as a Truck that often.  Can we get the function we need without all the weight and wasting fuel? Can a small trailer do the job instead of a truck?

That’s a great question which has tickled me for a long time.  However, the answer is not simple, so let’s explore a little.

Of course, this discussion is a moot point when the truck is a status symbol or a social statement.  There is a lot of that too, but for this article, we’ll address the hauling / utility functions.

For Transparency  . . .  I have almost always owned a truck, so I only live part of this.  I grew up working farms, driving trucks, tractors, etc..  Most of my life I’ve been hauling material or equipment for myself, for friends, and for customers.  Seems like I’m forever loading and unloading the truck and/or a trailer.  I once suggested trading in the truck, but my wife just laughed, then said “That will never work, you I couldn’t live without a truck.”  Hmmm, from the one who knows me best.

The point is, I believe in using trailers.  I think many people can substitute a trailer for a truck jut fine, but for others, not so well.  And, I suppose it really comes down to “How often do you use a truck as a truck?”  In my case, it’s frequently using the truck AND the trailer together — but that’s another story.

Buy A Trailer Instead of a Truck?

Many years ago I came onto a forum that focuses on vehicle fuel efficiency.  They cover a lot of topics surrounding the subject, but the one that caught my attention first is titled  Buy a trailer (instead of a pickup truck).  That thread starts in 2013, and it’s still expanding.  If you have time, there are a ton of good ideas in there.  (Also a bunch of non-sense, which makes it fun.)  Most important, the ideas come from a lot of perspectives.

So, what do you think?  Can a trailer really replace a truck?  Can a trailer actually be better than a truck?

Obviously we must make sure our car (or other passenger vehicle) can tow a trailer.  Almost every vehicle can tow something, it’s just a matter of setting it up properly.  Like this tiny trailer for his little business, a small car can tow the right type of trailer.  Use this article to find out how much your vehicle can tow.

A Trailer Instead Of A Truck

This is a great example of using a trailer instead of a truck.  Kudo’s to him.

Trailer Advantages

Of course, a list of advantages for a trailer instead of a truck is full of assumptions.  An advantage for some is a disadvantage to others, so consider the circumstances.  Also, some credit for this list goes to the blog notes above.

  1. Trailers are inexpensive, especially compared to a truck.
  2. Trailers cost much less to upkeep — oil changes, tires, maintenance.
  3. If they do have a problem, or incur damage, trailers are pretty cheap to repair.
  4. Overall, fuel economy can be much better (smaller car, then only use the trailer when it’s needed).
  5. In most places, trailers cost very little to license.
  6. Trailers are usually within the insurance of the tow vehicle.  No need to buy extra.
  7. Most places don’t require annual inspection or testing.
  8. Towing with a MinivanMost trailers are lower to the ground, and therefore easier to load and unload.
  9. When driving, the weight is lower.
  10. If you need to make changes, trailers are pretty easy and not too expensive to customize or modify.
  11. Pickup trucks have limits for bed size – most on the road are now “short beds”.  On the other hand, even a small trailer (like a 4×8 or 5×8) can often haul more.
  12. When it’s not needed to haul things, the trailer doesn’t need to go out.  No wear and tear.
  13. Like the trailer in this photo, it’s easy to have functional advantages over a truck, like the large tailgate/ramp, the motorcycle wheel cage, and the extra toolbox.

Again, these are subjective, and some — like hauling a lot more — require a sufficient tow vehicle.  For large hauling duties, then a truck may actually be required for towing, which is contrary to this discussion.  Anyway, take it within the scope of intent.  There really are a lot good of advantages.

Trailer Disadvantages

While the list of advantages is long, there are a few very important disadvantages.  When we think about what it takes to substitute a trailer instead of a truck, just one big disadvantage can spoil the plan.

  1. Trailers require storage space.  They’re like an extra vehicle (almost), that doesn’t go out very often, and they need space.
  2. Trailers that are not used very often still need maintenance once in a while.  You have to plan for that — like putting air in the tires after it sits for a long time.
  3. Many people find it difficult to drive and maneuver a trailer.  It’s a skill you can learn, however, so don’t let this stop you.
  4. When comparing to a truck, you must be more purposeful taking the trailer.  It’s easy to be spontaneous with a truck for ease of instant load carrying access.

Rent One InsteadWe should also point out that some disadvantages can be overcome by renting a trailer instead of owning one.  That way, you have access to many sizes, and you don’t have to maintain it, or store it.  Plus, if you don’t use it very often, it’s probably cheaper.  Look for local rentals not just the big ones like U-Haul.

Truck Advantages

To be fair, we need to look at the advantages of a truck.  While some truck advantages are the trailer disadvantages, it’s worth noting the differences.

  1. The opposites of the trailer disadvantages #’s 1, 3 & 4 above.
  2. The common pickup truck of today is not only good at hauling things, they are also pretty good for hauling people.  If we want to save energy with a car, we must also look at this truck advantage.
  3. Trucks can have 4-wheel drive and go places that are difficult with a smaller car, light SUV pulling a trailer.
  4. When capacity really matters, you can always add a trailer to a truck.  And, trucks usually have a higher trailer towing capacity than a car.

Truck and Trailer Advantage

Adding A Trailer Instead Of A Truck

It’s one thing to replace a truck with a car and trailer, yet it’s quite another if you don’t already have a truck.  If you downsize from a truck there are the obvious moments of missing the capacity.  And, the cost to buy a car is still pretty high.

Very Small TrailerOn the other hand, if you want a truck, or need one occasionally, but don’t have one now, this is a great option.  A new trailer is much cheaper than a truck, and the increases in capacity are instant.

No matter where you fall in the spectrum, the concept of using a trailer instead of a truck is an interesting proposition.  Again, for some it can work, for others, not so well.  If it works for you, and you want to build a trailer, we have lots of trailer plans.

We have just scratched the surface with this topic, so feel free to leave a comment and share your perspective.  Are there advantages or limitations I’ve missed in the lists above?  Thank you in advance for your contributions.  Have a wonderful day.

No one has share their thoughts...be the first!

No one has share their thoughts...be the first!

Leave a Comment

We Found These For You . . .

Product
16K by 20' Flat Deck Trailer

When heft is on the agenda, consider this beefy version of our 20’ length deck-over trailer plans.  With many options like all our trailers, this tandem axle is super heavy duty for rigorous jobs.

Product
4' x 8' - 3500# Torsion Axle Trailer

Fully Engineered Blueprints are just the start with these Torsion Axle Utility Trailer Plans.  With the deck a little larger than tradition, you can put true 4' x 8' cargo inside!  Up to 3500 lbs.

Article
The Car Parking Stop Solution!
Yeah, I know, most of the world doesn’t like or use the parking brake any more.  Yet, some of us still prefer a manual transmission for the driving experience — and rely on the parking brake.  So, what happens

Read The Article

Product
i-Beam Connector Clamp Bracket

A simple, mechanical, I-Beam connector clamp made from common materials as a solution for anchor positioning, and to enhance flexibility with a Gantry Crane.  Matches I-Beam flange angles.  Free Plans.

Article
I-Beam Clamp Introduction
Introducing a new product to the Mechanical Elements family of Do-It-Yourself Plans — the gantry crane I-Beam clamp.  A simple product we give as Free Plans in our launch celebration!  Well, is it really FREE Plans?  Yes.  Use the coupon…

Read The Article

Product
Mechanical Elements 4x8 Utility Trailer Plans

A small-ish, yet really tough little trailer.  Get these single axle 4x8 Utility Trailer Plans to get the jobs done.  With a total capacity of 3500 lbs., trailers built from these plans will work hard.

Article
Good Trailer Design Article Updates
The most popular pages on Synthesis about Trailer Design now have a fresh revision.  May, 2017.  They include more content, more pictures, and a mobile friendly web design.

Read The Article

Product
4x6 Utility Trailer Plans - View 1

Smaller size Trailer Plans for the DIY Builder.  This 4x6 Utility Trailer has a 2000# axle capacity and lots of options for customizing.  While it may be smallish, it’s tough and capable just the same.

Article
Winner of the Visa Gift Card
We have a winner of the $100 Visa Gift Card!  We sent out the Photo request, and you responded.  Now the drawing, and the winner.

Read The Article

Article
How We Make The Plans
What goes into the engineering of Do It Yourself Plans?  How do we make them?  When you purchase and download project plans from Mechanical Elements, you get a TON of work and information, much more than first meets the eye.

Read The Article

Article
Example aluminum trailers
This question comes up often — because there are not many good plans for aluminum trailers out there.  We have great trailer plans, but none for aluminum.  Why?  As one of our Frequently Asked Questions, this one deserves a good…

Read The Article

Article
Learn To Calculate the Axle Position
Trailer axle position?  This is a good question.  Unfortunately, there is some popular, but misleading information around.  So, how do you know proper trailer axle position?  Here’s the whole answer,

Read The Article

Article
Metal Working Files In Action
Often misused and not very well understood — so goes the life of many metalworking files.  Yet, they still do things other tools can’t.  That makes them a tool worth knowing!

Read The Article

Product
Hoist Winch Pole Plans

Meet the "Winching Pole".  It’s a simple, mechanical, Out-of-the-Way Hoist Winch to make lifting with a gantry crane easy.  No chains in the way.  No climbing up for a come-a-long.  Plans also include a simple load leveler.

Article
Bend A Metal Bracket
There are a bunch of ways to bend metal for a bracket.  Do a search on YouTube and you’ll likely find several techniques.  Well, we don’t want to dis any of those because

Read The Article

Article
A Scary Trailer Along The Road
When things get weird, we all want to see them. While it's fun to laugh (or be shocked) by yourself, it's even more fun to share with friends. If you see rattle-trap trailers on the road, snap a shot or…

Read The Article

Article
Twisting Trailer Safety Chains
Should you twist trailer safety chains to make them shorter?  Certainly twisting them reduces the length so they don’t drag the ground.  That part is good.  However, there are big issues with twisting safety chains?

Read The Article

Article
Secure and Flat Trailer Frame Setup
Just how do you setup for building a trailer frame?  Seems simple enough, just layout all the frame members and start welding, Right?  Well, mostly, but there are some additional steps that will help it turn out better.

Read The Article

Product
Heavy Duty Gantry Crane Plans

The big one, actually the big many.  These Gantry Crane Plans include Engineering graphs to choose the beam and legs from 2000 lbs - 6000 lbs lifting capacity.  Free Standing, Large or Small, Wide or Narrow. Build to fit your…

Article
New Plans for a Perfect Size Homemade Crane
A New Size?  OK, MechanicalElements.com has Gantry Crane plans – for years.  Interestingly, one of our very first plans.  Now, we just released the Perfect Size Crane for your Garage. 

Read The Article

Leave a Comment