When Should I Build? – When Should I Buy?

Do you want a new Utility Trailer?  Or, an OHV Hauler?  We have plans for those, but the big question is:  When should you build your new trailer?  versus  When should you just go out and buy one?

These are great questions, and we have some opinions (not what you might first think).  While this discussion is in the context of trailers, the same is true for Gantry Cranes, Shop Presses, and many other DIY things we can build or buy.  Let’s look at several aspects of building a trailer one at a time.  We will end with a conclusion for each.

Material Cost To Build A Trailer

Build A Trailer From Raw MaterialCost is one of the big reasons people give for wanting to build a trailer.  Go look in a trailer yard and you might get sticker shock.  Search the ads and you might find only overpriced junk.  Often we feel it will cost less to build than to buy.  Is that really true?

Almost all of the new trailers you see on a lot are factory built.  Those factories buy their materials (steel, aluminum, etc.) at rock bottom prices because they purchase in very large quantities.  They also use the materials more efficiently because they build many trailers so they don’t have as much scrap per unit.  The same quantity pricing is true for all the components like Axles, Wheels, Tires, Hitches, bolts, wiring and more.

Conclusion:  For raw materials and for purchasing components, unless you have some amazing hook-up with a supplier, a factory buys everything cheaper.  Cost advantage for “Buy”.

What About Labor And Other Costs?

Factories have to pay people to build trailers.  They also pay to ship finished trailers to the dealer lots, and allow some profit margin for their retailers.  They must make a profit too.

Build A Trailer DIYDo-it-Yourself builders, do pay a higher price for materials (and components), and it does take us a lot longer to build a trailer than a factory.  But, we don’t pay shipping on the finished trailer, and we don’t pay retail profits.  (Well, not on the finished trailer.)  Our profit is effectively the pride of ownership, and a finished product that we made.

Labor, on the other hand, is something we pay in opportunity cost.  Time we spend to build a trailer is not paid, but it’s time that takes away from something else.  What is your time worth?  That’s the cost of your labor.  Yet, if you’re like me, the enjoyment of building and the satisfaction of producing something really great, is also part of the pay.

Conclusion:  There is a good case for DIY with the lower financial cost of labor, but labor cost alone is not really a convincing reason.  Satisfaction in your work, and pride of ownership, well, that’s another story.  Cost advantage for “Build”.

The Value Proposition

We will go into more of the details below, but one big cost factor is getting what you want.  If you buy a trailer, you might have to take what they have on the lot.  If you want something custom, or if you want something not on the lot, then it might take some time.  And, the extra options can be very expensive.

If you build a trailer, you can include more of the options you want, and adjust the size or Customize the trailer in other ways.  The cost for these improvements is just the time and materials necessary.  The one hiccup is that it takes a lot of time to build as comparing to buy.

Conclusion:  If you want some special, or custom options, the DIY approach is attractive for cost.  Cost advantage for “Build”.
On the other hand, it takes a lot more time to build than buy.  Advantage for “Buy” — unless you have to wait for months and months for a custom option.

So, When Should I Buy?

If you want or need a trailer that is just like the ones on the lot, then you should probably buy one.  In the end, factoring in the cost of materials, components, time for fabricating, building, painting, and extra tools you buy, it’s likely to cost more to build than to buy.

Is it heresy to say that? Keep in mind that I’m talking about a factory standard trailer.  If that fits your need, and it’s all that you want, then it’s probably better to just go out and buy one.  If cost is a concern, search the ads on Craigslist and other places.  It’s not uncommon to get a good deal on a standard type trailer.

Two other reasons to think twice before you build a trailer:  Tools & Space.  If you don’t have the right tools (or have access to needed tools), building will be much more difficult.  Also, you will need plenty of space to setup and build a trailer.

Finally, if you need a trailer right now, it’s hard to build one really quick.  Better to just buy (or rent) what you need, then worry about building something later.  That is if you are so inclined.

Why Build A Trailer?

Utility Trailer Options AnimationBuilding a trailer is a wonderful experience.  If you’re thinking about this kind of project, there are lots of reasons for building, and many may apply.  Here are the reasons I see to build a trailer:

Functional Reasons:
  1. If you want something different from the standard factory trailer, definitely build it.  When building, you can customize the width, the length, the axle placement, tongue length, etc..
  2. If you want custom options – like certain sides, a specific tailgate, a given spare tire placement (or none), a certain decking type, or any number of other options.  Building gives you the ability to customize the trailer any way you want.  You can make it perfectly fit your ATV, your tractor, your mowers, or whatever else you intend to carry.
  3. If you have a specific need, you can build a trailer for your Jeep (off-road camp combo) or your car (low, lean and efficient), or whatever you intend to pull it with.  Truly custom projects may have other economic considerations.
  4. When you’re building something truly unique, like your new Tiny House, build the trailer that gives it the best foundation.  Or, when adding a folding tongue or other major option.
  5. If you want a trailer that is robust from the start, build it.  Factories build trailers as cheap as possible to meet specifications and not much more.  They take short-cuts like using angle iron for the frame supported by short sides (which work great when loaded well, but fail if the sides get damaged or if the trailer is loaded obnoxiously).  You can certainly build one better.
  6. When you build, you can address things like trailer bounce right from the beginning.  You can bias your efforts to the things you feel are functionally important.
Intrinsic Reasons:
  1. Then, there’s the pride of ownership.  Once you build a trailer that is really great, you’ll have payback every time you see it.
  2. Finally, if you love building — if creating is part of your mental relaxation — then build a trailer, for sure.  It’s a perfect project.  (Personally, I almost always like the shop better than the couch, so I get it.)
  3. If you want a truly quality product.  Perhaps you are meticulous about how things look, or want a custom finish.  Quality is a great reason to build.
  4. Education.  There is nothing like the education that comes from a great DIY project.  You will learn a ton, and if you’re like me, your sons (or daughters) can learn right along with you.  (I have great memories of working with my sons in the shop. (I don’t have daughters, or they would probably be learning too.))

Conclusion:  No question, if you want something different, if you want something really robust, if you want something you can be super proud of, and if you have a love of creating and building, DEFINITELY, Build It !!

Build a Trailer for Your Needs

Final Thoughts – Summary

The case for building over buying is one of ending up with something that truly fits your needs.  As noted above, it’s not just a matter of cost, but also of enjoyment in the final product.  In our plans, we show lots of options, and we encourage customization.  Build a trailer that you’re proud of, and it will be a source of happiness for years to come.

I have always said, “Build it if you want something you can’t Buy.”  That means quality, toughness, customizations, opportunity, education, pride of ownership, etc..  That’s why I build.

For your tiny house, the foundation is the key to almost all other parts of the project, so yes, build that to meet your needs.  We have some great plans to start with including a 20′, a 24′ and a 30’/32′ option to choose from — and customize.

Another point that we sometimes dismiss — enjoying the process.  The love of the journey!  Learning and expanding in ways that provide enjoyment is pretty important.  It adds richness to our lives.  Don’t discount that.

I might add that there is also a priceless education that comes from building something, especially if that’s not what you do every day.  Learning more about yourself and about how to do things will benefit you much farther than just the accomplishment of what you build.  I say “priceless” because there is no better way to learn than to do-it-yourself!

Good Luck with All Your Projects!

Comments

Subscribe
Notify of
1 Comment
Inline Feedbacks
View All Comments

We Found These For You . . .

Product
12K Equipment Trailer Plans

For hauling cars or equipment, the key is always full strength, so this trailer is a Heavy Duty I-Beam design with a Low Fixed Deck.  12,000 lbs Capacity and 18.5' length.  This car trailer will do the job.

Article
Plans In Metric
Virtually everything on the internet is by definition “World Wide”.   Even though Mechanical Elements (Synthesis Engineering Services) is physically located in the USA, we have a world audience, so it’s a fair question

Read The Article

Article
Mount A Trailer Axle
Of all the important things to do when building a trailer, getting axle(s) right is near the top of the list.  It is the position on the trailer, yes, and proper alignment as well.  In this article we look at…

Read The Article

Article
Gantry Crane Failure Modes
There are a lot of ways to abuse a crane.  We won’t go into those, but let’s do take a minute on crane failures and what they look like. 

Read The Article

Article
Ouch, Cracked Frame
This is a Customer Story about a crack in a trailer frame.  Finding these can be really scary, but finding them at this stage is a whole lot better than finding them after a catastrophic failure.

Read The Article

Product
Tilt Top Trailer Conversion

Build a Tilt Trailer by 'Converting' our standard, single axle Utility Trailer Plans.  Works with our 6' and 6'10" width, 3500# Trailer Plans, and is compatible with both leaf springs and torsion axles.

Product
Trailer 5 x 8 - 3500 lbs Torsion Axle

  Designed specifically for a Torsion Axle, these 5' x 8' utility trailer plans include a 3500# capacity, and many options to choose for making the trailer meet your needs.  And, they are fully Engineered so you can build with…

Article
Timbren Axle-Less Trailer Suspension
Customer Question:  “What do you think about the Axle-Less trailer suspension?  Is it good?”  Can I use it with the Mechanical Elements trailer plans?  . . .  You ask (actually a few of you are asking) and pointing to

Read The Article

Article
Trailer Wheel Bolts
A friend asked me this question, along with the companion of “How Tight?”  The last thing we want is to lose a wheel — because it will not only delay our trip, but a wheel coming loose can do serious…

Read The Article

Article
Don't Look at the Mig Welding
I grew up with a fascination for metals.  My father was a woodworker, and taught me young, so I have always built stuff from wood.  Yet, metal is different, and welding beats glue in the fun department any day!  And…

Read The Article